What makes selecting the ideal table for dining or a kitchen excellent is the fact that you can actually choose, and from several options at that. You find yourself being overwhelmed as one would when trying to settle between a unique eye-caching live edge dining table versus a more classic table in the traditional sense. Both have their own appeal and pros and cons, so the perfect choice will simply depend on your style preference, budget, and how you intend to use the table.
Let’s dive right into what makes each one unique and discover which one would be best suited for your home.
What is a Live Edge Table?
Before we talk about comparisons, let’s just talk about what a live edge table really is. The live edge table basically utilizes the natural edge of the wood, in most cases leaving it looking raw and organic. It takes the form of a living tree; the natural curves and shapes of the wood are all preserved to result in something unique and artistically crafted. Some of the popular materials for live edge tables include walnut, oak, and maple but the live edge walnut table is one of the favorites because of its rich tones, dark colors, and durability.
The term “live edge” has more to do with rustic or naturalistic interior styles, though it’s versatile enough to fit modern or industrial-themed spaces. They can take different forms, such as the stunning live edge dining table that can be the focal point of your dining room or the live edge kitchen table for a perfect cozy breakfast nook. Not to forget the live edge coffee table, a much more compact version that is ideal for adding a certain flair to a living room.
Advantages of Choosing a Live Edge Dining Table
1. Unique Aesthetic Appeal
This would be unique in itself due to the live edge dining table. Each piece will always have its grain, knots, and shape, thus having no two tables alike, which is a great attribute if you’re looking for a table that serves the purpose of a piece of art, especially if someone appreciates the look and feel of natural wood. These tables in live edge walnut are so attractive with rich colors and clear grain patterns that easily capture the attention of people.
2. Natural, Organic Feel
For those who want a little bit of the outdoors to come inside, a live edge table is the ticket for that earthy feel. The natural edges of the wood create an organic flow that can make a dining room or kitchen warm and cozy and connected to nature. In spaces where modern or industrial designs dominate, a live edge kitchen table or dining table can bring a softer, more natural element to balance the look.
3. Customization Options
Because live edge tables are handmade, they often are very customizable. Whether you’re commissioning a custom dining table from a furniture manufacturer or picking the size and finish of pre-made, live edge tables offer loads of options. You can pick the type of wood, the size, and even the base design, which could be anything from metal to wood or even acrylic for that modern twist. Custom dining tables will grant you greater control over the end product.
Drawbacks to Choosing a Live Edge Dining Table
1. Relatively Much More Expensive
A live edge table typically runs more than your traditional tables, purely because of the craftsmanship. It is an entire process, from the quality wood selected to the skilled work put into making it an investment piece. Custom dining tables with a live edge tend to be much costlier, especially if created from premium woods like walnuts. Even though the cost is reflective of what is unique and quality, do remember if your budget is limited.
2. Possible Maintenance Problems
Since live edge tables are made from natural wood, they may be harder to maintain. Wood is bound to warp or crack over time due to the change in humidity and temperature. In addition, it reveals scratches and stains more readily because the edges are raw and untreated. Frequent sealing, polishing, and perhaps refinishing are in order if you still want your live edge table to look as good as new.
3. Limited Style Compatibility
While live edge tables are very versatile, they are not suitable for every decor style. If your home leans heavily toward classic or ultra-modern decor, the rustic or organic look of a live edge table may be out of place. Some people enjoy mixing styles, though, so it really depends on personal preference. A live edge coffee table may be better suited to more modern or minimalist homes than a larger dining table, for instance.
What about Classic Tables?
Having already mentioned live edge tables, let’s now talk about classic tables. Traditional tables have clean defined lines and are basically constructed either in rectangular, round, or square shapes. They can be made of wood or metal and easily fit most interior styles. A traditional table can be a simple or elaborate choice to fit your needs. Traditional tables generally offer more predictability in their look as compared to live edge tables.
Advantages of Going for a Traditional Table
1. Classic, Old-Timer Look
Traditional tables have a classic timeless appeal and can easily fit almost any decor style. From classic wood tables to glass-topped designs, traditional tables look more structured and polished than modern ones. These look great for those who opt for a clean and not cluttered aesthetic and don’t want furniture that easily changes with trends.
2. Lower Maintenance
Most traditional tables are built to last and are not too fussy about maintenance. Unlike live edge tables, which may need to be sealed or polished periodically, traditional tables are generally more tolerant. Depending on the material, they can be cleaner to maintain and less susceptible to scratches or dings, making them a perfect choice for families or households with young children.
3. Broad Style Compatibility
Traditional tables come in a wide range of styles, from farmhouse and rustic to mid-century modern and industrial. This means you are likely to find a traditional table that will fit into your decor. You can also have a custom dining room table made for you, which will allow you to have a piece that fits your needs perfectly, blending the stability of a classic table with personalized touches.
Disadvantages of Choosing a Traditional Table
1. Lack of Uniqueness
Because traditional tables are everywhere and often mass-produced, they can lack the specialness of a live edge table. Sure, you can always add some personality with a custom dining room table, but it probably won’t have that “one-of-a-kind” feel of a live edge option.
2. Not Much Wow Factor
If you’re looking for a conversation piece that will “wow” your guests or surprise them with an unexpected look in your room, then a live edge piece will be more impactful than a traditional table. Traditional tables are beautiful, but they usually don’t make for good conversation pieces or statement items like a live edge dining table does.
Conclusion
Each live edge and traditional table has its own unique advantages, so there is no wrong choice. Whether you choose a live edge walnut table, a custom dining room table, or something more standard and traditional, take into consideration how the table fits into your lifestyle, budget, and design vision. A dining table is after all a gathering place for friends and family, so whatever you choose, it should be something you love and serve your space well.